The Post’s Fake News on Dragonflies
- Being Human
- Being Outside
- Boston Globe
- Earth and Sky
- Photography and Optics
- What's This?
The Washington Post published an article yesterday blaming rainfall and mosquitoes for elevated dragonfly activity this summer. Fake news! Here’s an unabridged version of the letter to the editor I just send to The Post:
To the Editor:
As The Post reported on August 13, dragonflies may indeed be more active this summer. But rainfall and mosquitoes probably have nothing to do with it.
Dragonflies spend most of their lives not on the wing but underwater as nymphs. So the destiny of this summer’s dragonflies was actually set in motion a year or more ago — in rivers, wetlands, lakes and ponds where dragonflies grew up. Rather than rain and mosquitoes, what determined the fate of this summer’s dragonflies was:
– how many dragonflies were on the wing last summer (or summers before) to mate and produce eggs that would go on to become this summer’s dragonflies;
– availability of aquatic prey (mostly other insects) for nymphs to feed on while they matured in our waters;
– the rate of predation on the nymphs by fish or even by other nymphs (yeah, they sometimes eat one another); and
– water conditions where the nymphs matured: pollution, temperature and winter freezing, for example.
Yes, once on the wing, adults might live a bit longer if they find mosquitoes, but I doubt it. It’s not as if these insects sit around and mope over a lousy mosquito crop. They find other insects to eat.
Any perception of increased activity could be explained by the regular summer abundance of a few conspicuous species, including Common Green Darner (Anax junius), Wandering Glider (Pantala flavescens), Black Saddlebags (Tramea lacerata) and others that frequent urban and suburban habitats.
Associating rainfall to dragonfly activity is like crediting Hurricane Harvey with the Houston Astros’ 2017 World Series victory. The Astros won because of the talent they raised in their farm system (and, of course, the late-season trade for Justin Verlander). Dragonflies are no different. To keep them healthy, we need to protect the rivers, lakes and wetlands where they grow up.
President, Dragonfly Society of the Americas
Excellent educational response!
I love it! And the increase in Monarchs this year are because of the historic run by the Boston Red Sox!
My spirit guides! I love it when I see the “Big Boppers” swarming around on a humid summer’s evening.
you are the BOMB! i can’t wait to get these emails from you. ps, hope they catch the grammatical error in the third bullet sentence. 🙂
My problem is what is the WP problem with dragonflies?
Science. It’s important. Thank you.
Way to set the record straight! And fascinating, too.
Bravo Bryan!! Great letter.
Great writing and educating as always, Brian.
Go, science! and, scientists!
Of course! Excellent letter.
Good letter Bryan. It’s a dirty job, but someone’s gotta try to keep ’em honest!
You tell ’em Bryan!